Contributions Workshop 3.3.C:
Transforming the societal framework to foster the sustainability of Mountain agro-food systems
ID: 249
Workshop & Poster
Unleashing endogenous mountain community potentials
Keywords: visioning, creative society, living labs, open workshops, sustainable innovation
Erdmann, Lorenz
Fraunhofer Institute for Systems and Innovation Research ISI, Germany
Many debates on the potentials of mountain regions appear detached from real life – with its value changes, opportunities elsewhere and actual living choices. Worldwide, regions are competing for talent to establish innovation ecosystems, e.g. comprising digital and bio technology, media and creativity, as a sound basis for future prosperity. Such innovation hubs are also encountered in mountain regions, but not specific for them. There is a clear need to identify and mobilize endogenous resources of mountain regions that are, first, rooted in the social capital of its dwellers (e.g. propensity to innovation) and, second, make use of unique location factors (e.g. landscape views stimulating creativity).
My contribution to the workshop will include the application of my expertise, on creative communities and innovation to the development of mountain regions, and on conceptual ways to enable mountain region dwellers to write their own future narratives (especially questions 1, 3).
(1) Our Fraunhofer ISI Visioning process makes internal values and visions of individuals explicit and provides effective procedures to develop a shared vision. Thereby mountain dwellers are empowered to tell narratives that are attractive to them, develop ownership and build social capital.
(2) Collaborative practices such as open workshops and living labs can orient creativity towards sustainability and people’s own needs, acknowledge the specificities of mountain regions and link up to other public, private and civic institutions. Open workshops can provide access to workspace, Know-How, tools and machines (e.g. 3D-printers) and local minerals. Living labs provide infrastructure, methods and support to develop and study new products, services and business models.
As a Fraunhofer ISI researcher, I bring in long professional experience in inter- and transdisciplinary research, including sustainability research, innovation research and foresight.
As a mountain passionate, I am eager to support the vitalization of mountain regions with my expertise.
Profile: https://www.isi.fraunhofer.de/en/competence-center/foresight/mitarbeiter/erdmann.html#expand-all
Real-world foresight as a catalyst for change in mountain areas
List of my competences and references:
- visioning
- explorative and transformative scenarios and narratives
- experimental practices (Living Labs, Open Workshops, etc.)
- horizon scanning
ID: 360
Workshop & Poster
Knowledge of the past- the way for future!
Keywords: traditional knowledge, gender, himalaya, vulnerability, food and nutrition security
SOGANI, REETU; SINGH, SATYENDRA
CHINTAN INTERNATIONAL TRUST -INDIA, India
People in the Himalayas have difficult conditions of living -remoteness, inaccessibility, forest degradation, difficult terrain and so on.Therefore, they gradually evolved their own adaptation mechanisms to overcome challenges posed by nature. Dependence on Traditional methods of Farming , Natural Resource Management , Health care Practices has been very effective in helping them secure sustainable livelihoods in these difficult conditions of living, all these years.
Mountain ecosystem is particularly susceptible to constant weather pattern changes. Climatic variability has serious and far reaching implications on the lives (especially of women, girls and the marginalized) of people through its Impact on Agriculture, Natural resources,Food & Nutrition Security and Livelihood.
Women constitute a very integral part of hill economy, in India. They have been contributing extensively towards farming, livestock care , sustainable use of natural resources etc through their continuous association with the surroundings as well as immense experience, knowledge and wisdom. With increasing male migration to the plains, her involvement and contribution has been increasing, but in absence of total ownership in assets and property, and thereby participation in decision making processes and forums , her condition and position is worsening at the household, and societal level.Climate variability, extreme events have aggravated her already vulnerable condition, in terms of her health and food security as well as access and control over resources. But at the same time it is extremely important and urgent that she becomes part of the processes as she can contribute immensely through her wealth of knowledge and experience especially in devising adaptation and mitigation strategies to address the issues of change.This paper is an attempt to share the perception, experiences,as well as adaptation strategies and innovations relating to agriculture and natural resource management, and their impact, introduced by community, especially women using their knowledge and local resources.
ID: 382
Workshop & Poster
Managing rural common pool resources in Italian mountain territories: a participation dilemma in a changing society
Dalla Torre, Cristina; Membretti, Andrea; Omizzolo, Andrea
Eurac Research, Italy
In mountain territories with a high anthropogenic density, competition arises over the different uses of common natural resources (soil, water, forests, etc.). Consequently, they become increasingly vulnerable to private appropriation processes that decrease their meaning as common resources and their social potential (Debarbieux & Price, 2016). On the other side, in depopulated areas, resources can suffer a loss of value (economic, social and cultural), due to lack of preservation and consequent degradation. Therefore, they are exposed to hydrogeological hazards, emphasized by the impacts of climate change. Moreover, the phenomenon of "new mountain dwellers" highlights how access to local resources can be difficult for newly settled people, facing management rules and customs that often tend to preserve the status quo (Membretti & Viazzo, 2017).
Rural common goods in mountain areas specifically suffer the consequences of these trends, as common pool resources in which exclusion of beneficiaries through physical and institutional means is especially costly, and exploitation by one user reduces resource availability for others (Ostrom, 1999). Therefore, they are subject to an increasingly relevant participation dilemma for their management and use. Considering that demographic and social trends are modifying the age and cultural composition of the population that inhabits the mountain, it becomes relevant to think about access and decision-making rights over common goods (Viazzo, 2012).
We start from the hypothesis that the management of common goods should take in consideration the changing of societal composition and of climatic conditions, in the perspective to preserve and valorize them in the long term. Similarly, we also hypothesize that rural mountain commons should be managed under sustainability criteria. Such criteria concur to preserve them, valorize them and make them resilient towards new demographic changes and the impact of climate change.
In mountain territories with a high anthropogenic density, competition arises over the different uses of common natural resources (soil, water, forests, etc.). Consequently, they become increasingly vulnerable to private appropriation processes that decrease their meaning as common resources and their social potential (Debarbieux & Price, 2016). On the other side, in depopulated areas, resources can suffer a loss of value (economic, social and cultural), due to lack of preservation and consequent degradation. Therefore, they are exposed to hydrogeological hazards, emphasized by the impacts of climate change. The physical-geographical characteristics of the territories also contribute to determine, on the one hand, the over-exploitation of some resources (watercourses for hydroelectric power, slopes for skiing, etc.) and, on the other hand, their abandonment (isolated pastures and mountain huts, forests far from paved, drivable roads, etc.). The morphological specificities as well as changing resource-dependency attitudes and production practices in the mountain territories strongly influence the level of intensity in use of rural mountain common pool resources. Some examples are the dismissal of the practice of wood making for wood heating, attitude change from hunting for survival to sport and leisure, mountain pasturing from a necessity to a touristic attractiveness (Gri, 2008).
The poster presents different regimes of property and use rights of common pool resources, considering collective property, public ownership, bottom-up participatory action, communitarism Vs. universalism in the access to common goods. It will show the implication that each type of right has facing relevant mountain-specific demographic trends such as the arrival of newcomers (highlanders, migrants), low fertility, aging communities, depopulation and overpopulation of some areas, economic leverages and climate change impacts. Concrete insights are collected starting from an expert workshop that the authors have organized on the status quo in the selected study region of Triveneto (Trentino-Alto Adige, Veneto, Friuli).
ID: 193
Workshop & Poster
New Farming as an example of Social innovation responding to challenges of inner mountain areas of Italian Alps
Keywords: Neo-rurals; Social Innovation; Community Development; New Farming, Alps
Gretter, Alessandro1,2; Dalla Torre, Cristina3; Maino, Federica3; Omizzolo, Andrea3
1Fondazione Edmund Mach, Italy; 2University of Innsbruck, Institute of Geography, Austria; 3EURAC Research, Italy
Changes occurred in the socio-economic framework since late 1960s have disrupted the multi-centennial balanced models of organisation in mountain communities, leading to a series of problematics in the socio-economical, cultural and environmental spheres. Mountain communities, independent or with the support of local and regional authorities, tried to halt or reverse these processes. In some cases, the effort is not intended only as collective, but either as the sum of different individuals, belonging or related to the community. In fact, processes of social innovation arised sparsely in various alpine territories, and many of them are connected to a novel interest in the primary sector by locals and new residents. The combination of both, but not exclusively, could be considered as generating “New Farming”. Authors present two cases identified in the north eastern part of the Italian Alps, which can be associated to this phenomenon. One have been analysed as external initiative, in the other authors have been involved in supporting the ongoing processes. Among the emerging common elements, it can be identified as multi-functionality, new job opportunities and profiles, larger social effects and the presence of a series of barriers. At present time pathways - actions and projects of social innovation, which are able to anticipate the changes and challenges of the future- seem to be not properly addressed and deserve a major attention.